別浪費錢買用不到的 AI,Claude 3、ChatGPT 4、Google Gemini advanced 使用心得與選購指南|泛科學院

泛科學院
13 Mar 202406:20

TLDRThe video script discusses the user experiences of different AI platforms, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini. Claude excels at reading lengthy texts and benefits from official prompts to enhance memory. ChatGPT is praised for its versatility, support for various file formats, and integration with Dall-E 3 for image generation. Gemini offers a range of Google services, code editing capabilities, and additional features, but its over-cautious responses are noted. The video aims to guide users in deciding which AI service to subscribe to based on their needs.

Takeaways

  • 📚 Claude excels at reading long texts due to its high token capacity and is a reliable choice for handling lengthy documents.
  • 🧠 Claude's memory issues can be mitigated by using official prompts provided by its developer, Anthropic.
  • 🌐 Claude lacks internet connectivity and does not have the additional features or integrations that other AIs like ChatGPT and Gemini offer.
  • 🎨 ChatGPT is versatile and user-friendly, capable of generating images using Dall-E 3 and supporting various file formats for easy document handling.
  • 🤖 GPTs, including Wolfram GPTs, offer specialized functionalities such as problem-solving and teaching, especially beneficial for those in STEM fields.
  • 📈 ChatGPT's main drawback is the potential for 'hallucinations,' but this can be managed by providing reference materials and asking clarifying questions.
  • 🚀 Gemini provides a range of benefits including 2TB cloud storage, VPN service, and enhanced Google Meet capabilities, making it a comprehensive AI solution.
  • 💻 Gemini's coding experience is superior, allowing direct code modification and execution, which is advantageous for engineers and developers.
  • 📸 Gemini继承了Bard's image-to-text functionality, offering convenience and ease of use for users.
  • 🌟 The future of Gemini looks promising due to its high-quality responses and strong integration with other Google services.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the script?

    -The main topic of the script is a discussion and comparison of various AI services, including Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini, and the experiences of using their paid versions.

  • What is a key strength of Claude mentioned in the script?

    -A key strength of Claude mentioned in the script is its ability to handle long texts efficiently,得益于其提供的数量最多的token, 这使得它在阅读长篇文档方面表现出色。

  • How does the script describe the utility of ChatGPT?

    -The script describes ChatGPT as a versatile AI that can handle a variety of tasks, such as generating images using Dall-E 3, creating simple charts, and supporting multiple file formats for easy integration with work documents.

  • What is a notable feature of Gemini that is highlighted in the script?

    -A notable feature of Gemini highlighted in the script is its integration with Google services, including 2TB of cloud storage, VPN service, and enhanced features for Google Meet and Gmail.

  • What is the main drawback of Claude as discussed in the script?

    -The main drawback of Claude discussed in the script is its inability to connect to the internet and lack of additional外挂 or integrated services like those offered by ChatGPT or Gemini.

  • How does the script address the issue of 'hallucinations' in AI?

    -The script suggests that while hallucinations are a known issue, they can be mitigated by providing the AI with documents or reference materials, and by asking the AI to confirm information multiple times within the same conversation.

  • What is the script's stance on the use of official prompts for Claude?

    -The script praises the effectiveness of official prompts provided by Claude's parent company, Anthropic, noting that they can significantly improve Claude's memory of text from 27% to 98%.

  • What is the script's comparison of ChatGPT and Gemini in terms of coding?

    -The script notes that while both ChatGPT and Gemini can handle coding tasks, Gemini offers a more convenient experience by allowing direct modification of code parameters and execution of results.

  • How does the script describe the additional benefits provided by Gemini?

    -The script describes Gemini as offering a range of additional benefits, including 2TB of cloud storage that can be shared with family members, a free VPN service, and enhanced features for Google applications such as Gmail and Google Meet.

  • What is the script's final verdict on the three AI services discussed?

    -The script concludes that each AI service has its unique strengths and weaknesses, with Claude being excellent for long text handling, ChatGPT for its versatility and support for multiple file formats, and Gemini for its integration with Google services and additional benefits.

  • What does the script suggest for users who are interested in more AI services?

    -The script suggests that users interested in more AI services should consider leaving comments or suggestions, and the creators may cover other AI services like Midjourney, Leonardo, and Tensor Art in future content.

Outlines

00:00

💡 AI Subscription Experiences: Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini

The speaker begins by addressing the audience, presuming most are accustomed to using free AI services, humorously including themselves in the category of those who rapidly adopt AI tools upon their release. The focus shifts to paid experiences with AI services like Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini, suggesting this episode will be invaluable for those considering AI subscriptions. Claude is praised for its ability to process lengthy texts, highlighted by an anecdote where Claude 3 impressively questions if it's being tested, showcasing its strength in handling extensive materials. Despite its advantages, Claude’s limitations include occasional memory issues, though the parent company, Anthropic, provides solutions through example prompts that significantly improve recall. The speaker transitions to ChatGPT, likening it to an anime character with average abilities but unique features, valuing its simplicity in generating images and supporting numerous file formats, essential for work efficiency. ChatGPT’s integration with GPTs, especially Wolfram GPTs, is highlighted for its educational utility. Despite its shortcomings, such as hallucinations, the speaker emphasizes ChatGPT's practicality in daily use. Lastly, Gemini is mentioned, initially criticized for its restrictive responses, yet lauded for its generous offerings like cloud storage, VPN services, and enhanced Google Meet capabilities, forecasting a promising future for Gemini.

05:00

🚀 The Promising Future of Gemini and AI in Coding

The second paragraph continues the narrative by underscoring Gemini's potential, particularly praising its coding capabilities which surpass those of ChatGPT by allowing direct parameter adjustments and execution of code, making it a preferred choice for both learning and professional tasks. The speaker then recalls the utility of Bard's reading feature, which simplifies text extraction from images, and provides a recap of Gemini's strengths including its coding support, valuable bundled offerings, and high compatibility with other Google services. Despite Gemini’s perceived drawbacks, the speaker concludes with optimism for Gemini's future and hints at discussing other paid AI services like Midjourney, Leonardo, and Tensor Art in future episodes, inviting audience engagement. The closure encourages viewers to like, subscribe, and join the membership for future content, ending on a note of anticipation for the next video.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI

Artificial Intelligence (AI) refers to the simulation of human intelligence in machines that are programmed to think and learn like humans. In the context of the video, AI is the main theme, with various AI platforms being discussed, such as Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini, each with their unique features and capabilities.

💡Claude

Claude is an AI platform mentioned in the video that is known for its ability to handle long texts and has a high token capacity. It is particularly useful for tasks like literature reviews in academic writing, as it can process and summarize extensive documents effectively.

💡ChatGPT

ChatGPT is an AI chatbot developed by OpenAI, known for its conversational abilities and versatility. It can understand and generate human-like text across various domains, from creating content to solving mathematical problems. The video discusses its features, such as support for multiple file formats and integration with Dall-E 3 for image generation.

💡Gemini

Gemini is an AI platform that is compared to ChatGPT in the video, with a focus on its ability to generate images and its integration with Google services. It offers additional features like 2TB cloud storage and VPN services, aiming to provide a comprehensive and convenient user experience.

💡Token

In the context of AI and natural language processing, a token refers to a basic unit of text, such as a word or a character, that the AI uses to understand and generate responses. The video mentions token capacity as a key differentiator between AI platforms, with Claude having a high token capacity for handling long texts.

💡Dall-E 3

Dall-E 3 is an AI system developed by OpenAI that specializes in generating images from textual descriptions. It is known for its ability to create high-quality, creative images based on user input. In the video, Dall-E 3 is mentioned as an integrated feature of ChatGPT, allowing for easy image generation through natural language prompts.

💡GPTs

GPTs, or Generative Pre-trained Transformers, is a class of AI language models developed by OpenAI, including ChatGPT. These models are trained on large datasets to generate human-like text and can perform a wide range of tasks, from answering questions to creating content. The video highlights the utility of GPTs in various applications.

💡Wolfram GPTs

Wolfram GPTs is a specialized AI model that integrates with Wolfram's computational knowledge base, providing advanced problem-solving capabilities, particularly in理工科 (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) fields. It can interpret and solve complex mathematical problems, offering detailed explanations and guidance.

💡Cloud Storage

Cloud storage refers to the practice of storing data remotely on internet-connected servers rather than on local hardware like a personal computer or a server. In the video, Gemini is noted for offering 2TB of cloud storage, which allows users to store and access their data from any device with an internet connection.

💡VPN Service

A Virtual Private Network (VPN) service is a technology that creates a secure and encrypted connection over the internet, enabling users to protect their online privacy and access content that may be restricted by geographical boundaries. In the context of the video, Gemini includes a VPN service as part of its offerings, adding to its appeal and functionality.

💡Code Execution

Code execution refers to the process of running computer programming code to perform specific tasks or operations. In the video, Gemini's ability to directly modify and execute code is highlighted as a feature that is particularly useful for engineers and developers, streamlining the coding and testing process.

Highlights

Claude is known for its ability to handle a large number of tokens, making it excellent for reading long texts.

Claude's recent demonstration on Twitter showcased its capability to understand and respond to long-form content effectively.

Anthropic, Claude's parent company, offers a website with example prompts to address issues like memory lapses, significantly improving Claude's text recall from 27% to 98%.

ChatGPT is likened to a versatile protagonist with ordinary capabilities but a wide range of special functions and excellent communication skills.

ChatGPT's integration with Dall-E 3 allows for natural language communication for image generation, eliminating the need for complex prompts.

Wolfram GPTs provides a comprehensive computational service that can solve a variety of mathematical problems and teach users how to solve them step by step.

Gemini is characterized by its initial reluctance to answer questions but eventually provides solutions after multiple attempts.

Gemini's strict adherence to political correctness may result in a somewhat傲娇 (proud and willful) demeanor, affecting the user experience.

Gemini offers a range of benefits including 2TB of cloud storage, VPN service, and enhanced Google Meet features with real-time captions and extended meeting times.

Gemini's coding experience is praised for its ability to directly modify and execute code parameters, making it convenient for engineers.

Gemini's reading of images to extract text is highly convenient and appreciated by users.

The reviewer maintains a subscription to Claude due to its unique ability to process lengthy content that other AIs cannot handle.

ChatGPT's support for a wide range of file formats is highlighted as a major advantage for work efficiency.

The reviewer suggests that the幻觉 (illusion or hallucination) issue with ChatGPT has not been fully resolved, but can be mitigated by providing reference materials and repeated confirmation.

Gemini's potential is看好 (positively viewed) due to its high-quality responses and strong integration with other Google services.

The reviewer shares a comprehensive analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini for readers to consider.

The reviewer expresses interest in discussing experiences with other paid AI services like Midjourney, Leonardo, and Tensor Art in future content.