AI music is OUT OF CONTROL (what the hell do we do?)

7 May 202410:29

TLDRThe video discusses the rapid advancement of AI in music and its potential impact on musicians. Despite initial skepticism, the host is impressed by the quality of an AI-generated blues guitar solo, noting the significant improvement from just five years prior. While AI is seen as incapable of replicating the human 'groove' and random creative elements, it is suggested that AI will become a tool for musicians rather than a replacement. The host also touches on the ethical considerations of AI in music, such as fair compensation for artists whose work is used to train AI systems. The video concludes with a positive outlook, encouraging viewers to embrace AI as a part of the music-making process and to focus on its ethical use.


  • 🎵 AI-generated music has advanced significantly in the past 5 years, evolving from a basic level to a highly sophisticated one.
  • 🤖 The current difference between AI and human musicians is the ability to 'groove', which AI has not yet mastered.
  • 🎸 Rhythm guitar playing is crucial for musicians and is a skill that distinguishes professionals from amateurs.
  • 🚀 AI's role in music is likely to be as a tool to assist musicians rather than replace them, which is already happening in the industry.
  • 🔍 AI can analyze vast amounts of data to create music that appeals to a broad audience, especially in pop music.
  • 🌟 The value of a good song is not diminished by AI's ability to write it; the industry is already saturated with excellent music.
  • 👤 The persona of the artist, their message, image, and style are more important than the music itself to many fans.
  • 🎶 There will likely be a counter-movement that values music made solely by humans, as people may seek more authenticity.
  • 🌐 The accessibility of music allows for a wide variety of tastes and preferences, and people can easily avoid AI-generated music if they choose.
  • 🎧 The conversation around AI in music should focus on ensuring ethical use and fair compensation for artists whose work is used to train AI systems.
  • 🌟 Musicians should not be disheartened by AI's capabilities; instead, they should see it as an opportunity to use AI as an instrument to enhance their art.
  • 💡 The enjoyment of creating music and the human experience it provides are irreplaceable by AI, regardless of technological advancements.

Q & A

  • What was the speaker's initial reaction to the AI-generated blues guitar solo?

    -The speaker was absolutely blown away by the AI-generated blues guitar solo, expressing surprise and concern about the advancement of AI in music.

  • How does the speaker describe the progress of AI in music composition over the past five years?

    -The speaker compares the progress to going from a 1920 Ford Model T to a 2024 GT super car, indicating a significant leap in capability and quality.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on the biggest difference between human and AI musicians?

    -The speaker believes the biggest difference is the groove, stating that robots can't groove yet and that this is a crucial aspect of rhythm guitar playing.

  • What is the purpose of the speaker's new course 'Into the Rhythm'?

    -The course is designed to help intermediate guitar players take their rhythm guitar playing to the next level by covering topics used by professional guitar players.

  • How does the speaker view the role of AI in the creative process for musicians?

    -The speaker suggests that AI will likely be used as a tool to assist musicians in their art rather than replacing them, and that AI's role is already becoming more prevalent in the industry.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the potential impact of AI on the value and integrity of music created by humans?

    -The speaker is not overly worried, arguing that the unique human experience and emotion that musicians bring to their craft cannot be replicated by AI. They also mention that the value of a good song is already quite low, so AI's ability to write good songs may not significantly impact the industry.

  • What does the speaker think about the ability of AI to innovate in music?

    -The speaker acknowledges that much of what musicians do involves copying and learning from influences, but they believe the truly innovative and random elements that make music magical, such as happy accidents, cannot be replicated by AI.

  • How does the speaker envision the future relationship between AI and live music?

    -The speaker is optimistic that there will be a demand for real, live human performances, and that AI will not diminish the value of human-made music. They suggest that AI might even lead to a society-wide appreciation for more authentic experiences.

  • What is the speaker's advice for those who are concerned about AI's impact on the music industry?

    -The speaker advises focusing on ensuring that AI's role in music is ethical, that artists are properly compensated for their work used to train AI, and that the ultimate goal is to benefit real humans.

  • What is the main argument the speaker makes against the idea that AI will replace human musicians?

    -The main argument is that the human element, including the ability to groove and the unique experiences and emotions that musicians bring to their work, cannot be replicated by AI.

  • How does the speaker describe the potential for AI to assist in the songwriting process?

    -The speaker describes AI as a tool that can generate options and provide inspiration to help songwriters overcome creative hurdles, without taking away from the artist's integrity.

  • What is the title of the speaker's new course, and what is the special offer for the first 50 enrollees?

    -The title of the new course is 'Into the Rhythm', and the special offer for the first 50 enrollees is a 50% discount off tuition.



🎵 AI and the Future of Music 🤖

The speaker expresses initial skepticism about AI replacing human musicians, emphasizing the importance of 'groove' and human elements in music. They recount their experience with AI-generated music, noting a significant improvement from five years prior. The speaker also discusses the potential impact of AI on the music industry, suggesting that while AI can replicate styles, it lacks the random and innovative elements that make music human. They propose that AI will be a tool for musicians, rather than a replacement, and predict a future where AI-generated pop music will be prevalent, but there will also be a counter-movement valuing human-made music.


🎶 The Role of AI in Music Creation 🤔

The speaker reassures that despite AI's advancements, the unique human experience in creating music cannot be replicated by AI. They predict that musicians will use AI as an assisting tool rather than it replacing them. The speaker also mentions that AI is already being used in various aspects of the music industry, such as mixing software and songwriting assistance. They argue that AI's ability to write good songs does not diminish the value of human artistry. The speaker suggests that the focus should be on ensuring ethical use of AI and fair compensation for artists whose work is used to train AI systems.


📢 Final Thoughts and Promotions 🎉

The speaker invites viewers to share their thoughts on AI in music in the comments section and reminds them of the ongoing enrollment for their 'Into the Rhythm' course, offering a discount for the first 50 enrollees. They also announce a clearance sale in their merch store to make room for new items. The speaker concludes by thanking the viewers, urging them to take care of themselves, each other, and the planet, and signs off as 'Samurai Guitarist', promising to see them again soon.



💡Artificial Intelligence

Artificial Intelligence (AI) refers to the simulation of human intelligence in machines that are programmed to think like humans and mimic their actions. In the context of the video, AI is used to generate music, specifically a blues guitar solo and a rock song, showcasing the rapid advancements in AI's ability to create complex and nuanced music that was once thought to be the exclusive domain of human musicians.

💡AI Generated Music

AI Generated Music is music that is composed and produced by artificial intelligence without human intervention. The video discusses how AI has evolved to create music that is increasingly sophisticated and difficult to distinguish from music composed by humans. It raises questions about the future of human musicians in light of AI's growing capabilities.


Groove in music refers to the rhythmic 'feel' or sense of propulsion that carries a tune. It is a fundamental aspect of rhythm guitar playing and is highlighted in the video as a key differentiator between human musicians and AI. The human element of groove is seen as something that AI has yet to master, giving human musicians an edge.

💡Rhythm Guitar

Rhythm guitar is a style of guitar playing that provides the chord progressions and rhythmic basis for a song. It is an essential part of a band's sound and is emphasized in the video as a critical skill for guitarists. The video suggests that the role of the rhythm guitarist in providing the 'groove' is something that AI has not yet been able to replicate.

💡Musical Influences

Musical influences are the artists, genres, or styles that inspire and shape a musician's work. The video discusses how musicians often train themselves by emulating their influences, and it questions whether AI could replicate this process. It also touches on the influence of The Beatles, a highly innovative band, as an example of how music is often a blend of various styles.


Innovation in music refers to the creation of new ideas, styles, or techniques that have not been previously explored. The video addresses concerns that AI may only be able to copy existing music and questions whether it can truly innovate. It suggests that while AI may not independently innovate, a creative human collaborator could guide the AI to produce innovative music.


DIY, short for 'Do It Yourself,' refers to the act of creating, modifying, or repairing something without the aid of experts or professionals. In the context of the video, DIY is associated with the random, spontaneous, and unique elements that human musicians bring to their music, such as John Lennon playing his guitar backwards or Ringo Starr drawing inspiration from an octopus during a vacation.


Consciousness in the context of AI refers to the self-awareness and cognitive abilities that are characteristic of human intelligence. The video mentions that AI is currently far from achieving consciousness, which limits its ability to independently create music with the same depth and nuance as humans.

💡Music Industry

The Music Industry encompasses the businesses involved in the production, distribution, and sale of music and music videos. The video discusses how AI has already infiltrated the industry, with AI mixing software, AI-designed guitar pedals, and AI-assisted songwriting sessions becoming more common. It suggests that AI is being used as a tool to assist human artists rather than replace them.

💡Artistic Persona

Artistic Persona refers to the public image or identity that an artist projects through their work and public appearances. The video argues that the persona, message, and style of an artist are more important to fans than the technical process of creating music. It suggests that even if AI plays a larger role in music creation, the human connection to the artist's persona will remain significant.

💡Pop Music

Pop Music is a genre of popular music that is characterized by its catchy melodies and wide appeal. The video speculates that pop music might be the area where AI has the most significant impact, as it can analyze vast amounts of data to create music that appeals to a broad audience. However, it also predicts a counter-movement that values music created solely by humans.


AI-generated music is evolving rapidly and has improved significantly in the past 5 years.

The speaker is impressed by the quality of an AI-generated blues guitar solo created by the website Yudo.

AI composition software has advanced from a 1920 Ford Model T to a 2024 GT super car in terms of music quality.

The biggest difference between human and AI musicians is the 'groove', which robots can't replicate yet.

The rhythm guitar role is the most important aspect of guitar playing, setting it apart from AI.

The speaker's new course, 'Into the Rhythm', aims to help intermediate guitarists improve their rhythm guitar skills.

AI's ability to copy and replicate musical styles is similar to how human musicians learn from their influences.

The Beatles' music was a mixture of various influences, but AI can't replicate the random, human elements that add magic to music.

A clever and creative person using AI software could potentially create something new and innovative.

Consciousness in software is unlikely, so AI is limited by human input.

AI has already infiltrated the mainstream, including music mixing software and AI-designed guitar pedals.

The value of a good song is already low, so AI's ability to write good songs may not significantly impact the industry.

The importance of music goes beyond the music itself, including the artist's persona, message, image, and style.

Pop music may see the most AI influence due to its need to appeal to a wide audience, which AI can analyze and cater to.

There will likely be a counter-movement against AI-made music, valuing human-created music more.

The speaker is optimistic about the potential for a society-wide demand for real, human experiences, including live music.

The conversation around AI should focus on ensuring it is ethical and beneficial to real humans.

AI's role in music should be seen as a tool to assist artists, not replace them.