What worries me most about AI art | Art Talk

Joao Marcedo
31 Mar 202407:31

TLDRThe speaker shares a personal journey of artistic appreciation, recounting a memorable museum visit with his girlfriend that sparked a deep connection with the exhibited landscapes. He reflects on the evolution of his understanding and love for art, from his early indifference to his current passion for both museum paintings and cave art. He also expresses concern about the potential of AI to diminish the depth and value of art, emphasizing the irreplaceable human element in creating and appreciating art's rich narratives and beauty.


  • 🎨 The narrator's initial indifference towards museums, despite being an artist, changed when visiting with his girlfriend, highlighting the importance of companionship in experiencing art.
  • 🖼️ A series of landscape paintings left a lasting impression on the narrator, evoking a sense of familiarity and connection with the unknown artist, transcending time and personal knowledge.
  • 👀 The act of closely observing the brushstrokes and colors on the canvases allowed the narrator to almost hear the artist at work and feel a deep connection to the creative process.
  • 🌳 The narrator's personal painting style is described as bold and imaginative, appreciating the simplicity and expressiveness of capturing nature with a few brushstrokes.
  • 🏛️ The transformative power of art education is emphasized, as the narrator's understanding and appreciation of both museum paintings and cave art increased through study.
  • 🖌️ Cave art is celebrated for its historical significance and aesthetic beauty, showing that the human need for creativity is ancient and universal.
  • 🌟 The impact of witnessing art in person versus through images is discussed, with the narrator expressing a desire to see the original cave paintings.
  • 🤖 Concerns about AI in the art world are raised, particularly the potential loss of depth and appreciation when art is generated by machines rather than humans.
  • 🎓 The value of art education is underscored, as it enables a deeper understanding and appreciation of art, which is essential for a fulfilling artistic experience.
  • 💖 The joy of sharing the art world with others is highlighted, as the narrator's appreciation for art grew alongside his relationship with his girlfriend.
  • 🌈 The narrator's newfound ability to see the layers of meaning and story in art, which is a personal and enriching experience, is celebrated.

Q & A

  • What was the speaker's initial attitude towards museums?

    -The speaker initially did not enjoy museums much, as they often felt the need to take a nap or escape when inside one.

  • How did the speaker's experience at the small museum with their girlfriend differ from their previous experiences?

    -This time, the museum visit seemed like something fun to do with their girlfriend, and the speaker had a memorable experience with a series of paintings that left a lasting impression on them.

  • What was the nature of the paintings that the speaker found particularly striking?

    -The striking paintings were plein air landscapes, impressionistic small canvases hung in a grid-like arrangement.

  • How did the speaker feel when observing the details of the artist's brushstrokes?

    -The speaker felt a deep connection with the artist, as if they could almost see the artist mixing colors on the wooden palette and creating the paintings.

  • What similarities did the speaker find between their own painting style and the ones at the museum?

    -The speaker loves to paint with big, bold brush strokes, similar to how the artist of the paintings at the museum captured scenes with energetic and precise strokes.

  • How does the speaker feel about the value of art and the role of AI in the art world?

    -The speaker appreciates the value of art beyond communication or ritual and is concerned that AI might not be able to fully appreciate the depth of art, potentially leading to a lack of value or depth in AI-generated art.

  • What did the speaker learn from studying cave art and their ancestors' need to create?

    -The speaker learned that even thousands of years ago, humans had a need to create beyond survival, and cave art served as both a form of communication and a medium of beauty, showcasing skill and energy in the artwork.

  • How has the speaker's appreciation for art evolved over time?

    -As the speaker studied art more, they began to see beauty where they were previously indifferent, including in museum paintings, cave art, and the natural world.

  • What is the speaker's hope for their future engagement with art?

    -The speaker hopes to continue learning to make better paintings and to keep enjoying art and connecting with other artists, as they believe the richness of art is best appreciated through personal experience and understanding.

  • Why does the speaker believe that an art degree is not necessary to appreciate art?

    -The speaker believes that while knowledge enhances the appreciation of art, the deep connection and love for art can be shared by individuals without formal education in the field, as it is a personal and unique experience.

  • What was the turning point for the speaker in terms of their appreciation for museums?

    -The turning point was when the speaker could finally understand and appreciate the art in museums, realizing that their previous boredom stemmed from a lack of knowledge about what they were observing.



🎨 The Artistic Connection

The speaker shares a personal story of visiting a small museum with his girlfriend, despite not usually enjoying museums. He describes an encounter with a series of paintings that left a lasting impression on him, evoking a sense of familiarity and connection with the unknown artist. The speaker reflects on his own approach to painting, appreciating the boldness and creativity involved. He draws a parallel between these museum paintings and the beauty found in cave art from prehistoric times, emphasizing the timeless human need to create and appreciate art. The speaker's journey from indifference to deep appreciation of art is highlighted, showcasing the evolution of his understanding and love for artistic expression.


🤖 AI and the Future of Art

The speaker expresses his concerns about the impact of AI on the art world, particularly the fear that AI might replace human artists. He worries that AI-generated art may lack the depth and value of human-created art, as AI artists won't be able to fully comprehend the reasons behind the aesthetics of their creations. The speaker asserts that the personal connection and the stories behind art are essential, which AI cannot replicate. He emphasizes the importance of continuous learning and the enriching experience of engaging with art, both as a creator and a viewer. The speaker concludes by encouraging others to appreciate art beyond the surface level and to connect with it on a deeper, more personal level.




A museum serves as a repository for art, history, and culture, offering a space for public exhibition. In the script, the museum symbolizes an initial reluctance towards traditional art spaces and later, a discovery of personal and emotional connections to art. The narrator's journey begins with a skepticism towards museums, viewing them as inducing boredom, but evolves into an appreciation through a shared experience with their girlfriend. This transformation underscores the narrative of growth and deeper appreciation for art beyond its surface value.


Impressionism is an art movement characterized by small, thin brush strokes, open composition, and emphasis on accurate depiction of light in its changing qualities. In the script, the narrator encounters impressionistic landscapes that evoke a sense of familiarity and connection, despite a temporal distance of a century. These paintings serve as a medium through which the narrator appreciates the nuances of artistic expression, recognizing a shared aesthetic and technique with the artist, thus bridging time and fostering a profound connection.

💡Artistic connection

Artistic connection refers to the profound bond felt between an artist and the viewer of their work, often transcending time and space. In the script, this connection is deeply felt by the narrator upon viewing the impressionistic landscapes, despite not knowing the artist personally. This bond is further amplified by the narrator's own artistic practices and appreciation for similar aesthetics, illustrating how art can create intimate connections and shared experiences across centuries.

💡Cave art

Cave art, the earliest known form of human artistic expression, consists of paintings, drawings, and engravings on cave walls. The narrator's reflection on cave art highlights its importance as a universal human impulse to create and communicate. The script emphasizes not only the communicative and ritualistic purposes of cave art but also its aesthetic value, suggesting a shared human desire for beauty and expression that connects contemporary audiences with their prehistoric ancestors.

💡Art appreciation

Art appreciation involves recognizing the value and beauty of art, understanding its context, and experiencing emotional and intellectual responses to it. Throughout the script, the narrator's journey from indifference to a deep appreciation for art exemplifies how knowledge, experience, and personal growth can enhance one's ability to appreciate art. This transformation is portrayed through encounters with museum paintings and cave art, revealing a newfound ability to see beauty in diverse forms of artistic expression.

💡AI in art

The script delves into the implications of artificial intelligence (AI) in the creation of art, expressing concerns over the potential loss of depth and appreciation in art produced by AI. The narrator worries that while AI can generate aesthetically pleasing images, it lacks the capacity to fully understand or appreciate the nuances of art. This perspective underscores a fear that the proliferation of AI in art could diminish the value of human creativity and the depth of connection that comes from shared human experiences and emotions in art.

💡Artistic skill

Artistic skill refers to the technical proficiency and creative abilities possessed by artists. The script highlights the narrator's admiration for the skillful execution of both the impressionistic paintings and cave art, noting the precision, gesture, and energy conveyed through brush strokes and lines of charcoal. This admiration for artistic skill underscores the narrator's commitment to mastering the fundamentals of drawing and painting, reflecting a broader theme of valuing craftsmanship and the tangible connection it provides to artists of the past.

💡Natural world

The natural world in the script symbolizes a source of inspiration and a canvas of inherent beauty that artists have sought to capture and interpret throughout history. The narrator's evolved appreciation for art extends to the natural world, seeing shapes and colors with a new depth of beauty. This perception illustrates the interconnectedness of art and nature, suggesting that a true appreciation for art encompasses an awareness of the beauty in the world around us.

💡Learning and growth

Learning and growth are central themes in the script, represented by the narrator's evolving understanding and appreciation of art. Initially indifferent to museums and traditional art forms, the narrator embarks on a journey of personal and intellectual growth that leads to a profound appreciation for artistic expression. This transformation is fueled by studying art history, mastering technical skills, and opening oneself to the emotional depths of art, illustrating how continuous learning enriches one's life and connections to others.

💡Shared experience

Shared experience, as depicted in the script, emphasizes the communal aspect of art appreciation and the bond it can forge between individuals. The narrator's decision to share their newfound appreciation for impressionistic paintings with their girlfriend highlights how art serves as a medium for connection and understanding. This moment captures the essence of shared experience in deepening relationships, fostering a mutual appreciation for beauty, and enabling individuals to see the world through a shared lens of artistic admiration.


The narrator's initial disinterest in museums despite being an artist.

The experience of visiting a small museum with the narrator's girlfriend and the impact it had.

A series of paintings that left a lasting impression on the narrator.

The feeling of familiarity and connection with the unknown artist through his work.

The narrator's personal painting style and how it relates to the museum's artwork.

The appreciation for the artist's skill in creating small, impressionistic landscapes.

The emotional connection and the sense of closeness the narrator felt with the artist despite not knowing their identity.

The narrator's art education background and its influence on their perception of art.

The discussion on the value of art beyond communication and ritual, as a medium of beauty.

The admiration for the prehistoric cave art and its timeless beauty.

The notion that art created by our ancestors reflects human nature and the need to create.

The impact of AI on the art world and the potential loss of depth and appreciation in AI-generated art.

The importance of personal connection and understanding in appreciating the full value of art.

The transformative experience of gaining knowledge in art and seeing beauty where there was once indifference.

The unique personal stories and emotions that traditional art holds, which AI cannot replicate.

The narrator's commitment to continue learning and growing as an artist to deepen their connection with art.