Is This Rooftop Turbine the Future of Energy… or an Old Idea?

Undecided with Matt Ferrell
14 May 202418:49

TLDRNorwegian company Ventum Dynamics has introduced the VX175, a shrouded rooftop wind turbine designed for deployment along the edges of large industrial and commercial buildings. The VX175 features a shroud that accelerates wind, allowing more air to pass through and potentially increasing power output. Initially thought to be inspired by Erasmus Darwin's 18th-century design, the VX175 is actually an evolution of the IMPLUX turbine invented by engineer Varan Sureshan. Unlike traditional turbines, the VX175 is stationary except for the rotor, reducing maintenance and noise. While not suitable for single-family homes, it is a good fit for apartments, commercial buildings, and is being developed in a larger version, the VX300, for industrial areas. The VX175 represents an innovative approach to harnessing wind energy in urban environments.

Takeaways

  • 🌪 The VX175 is a new rooftop wind turbine released by Norwegian company Ventum Dynamics, featuring a shroud that accelerates wind and allows a greater volume of air to pass through the turbine.
  • 🏢 The turbine is designed for deployment along the edges of large industrial and commercial buildings, similar to the Aeromine rooftop wind turbine.
  • 📚 The concept of using a shroud to amplify a turbine’s power output is not new, with researchers experimenting with this idea for decades.
  • 🤔 The VX175's design was initially misunderstood to be connected to an older concept, the Darwinian windmill, developed by Erasmus Darwin, but this was later clarified as a false notion.
  • 🔍 The actual origins of the VX175 come from the IMPLUX turbine, invented by engineer Varan Sureshan, and not based on Darwin’s design.
  • 🛠️ The VX175 is a DAWT (diffuser-augmented wind turbine), which is a class of wind turbine that uses a shroud or diffuser to increase power output by concentrating wind energy and reducing tip losses.
  • 🌬️ The turbine is omnidirectional, capturing energy from turbulent airflow common in urban environments, and is designed to be mounted on the tops of buildings.
  • ⚙️ Unlike traditional wind turbines, the VX175 has no moving parts except the rotor, which helps reduce maintenance costs and noise.
  • 💰 While the potential power output increase is significant, the economic practicality of shrouded turbines has been a consistent challenge, with many projects facing high costs and structural integrity issues.
  • 🏗️ Ventum's turbine is optimized for manufacturing and aims to bring wind turbines to more populated areas where traditional turbines may not be feasible.
  • 📈 A study from the University of Tehran showed that wind lens turbines (a type of DAWT) significantly reduced the levelized cost of energy and increased annual energy production.

Q & A

  • What is the unique feature of the Ventum Dynamics VX175 rooftop turbine?

    -The unique feature of the Ventum Dynamics VX175 rooftop turbine is its lantern-like structure, known as a shroud, which wraps around the body of the turbine. This shroud accelerates the wind, allowing a greater volume of air to pass through the turbine.

  • What is the historical misconception about the VX175 turbine?

    -The historical misconception about the VX175 turbine is that it is based on a design by Charles Darwin. However, the actual design is unrelated to Darwin's work and is a modern innovation by engineer Varan Sureshan.

  • Why is the VX175 turbine considered a DAWT?

    -The VX175 turbine is considered a DAWT (diffuser-augmented wind turbine) because it uses a shroud to concentrate wind energy, increase airflow, and improve power output, which is a distinct class of wind turbines.

  • What are the advantages of using a shroud in wind turbines?

    -The advantages of using a shroud in wind turbines include the concentration of wind energy, low exit pressure leading to increased airflow and faster wind speeds, avoidance of tip losses, and overall increased efficiency and power output.

  • Why might shrouded turbines be more practical for urban and residential areas?

    -Shrouded turbines might be more practical for urban and residential areas because they can make use of low wind speeds that are accessible from rooftops, potentially increasing the power output in areas where traditional turbines might not be cost-effective.

  • What is the main challenge faced by shrouded turbines?

    -The main challenge faced by shrouded turbines is their economic practicality. The cost of manufacturing and installing large shrouds on traditional turbines is often prohibitive, although companies like Ventum are working on designs optimized for manufacturing to overcome this issue.

  • How does the VX175 turbine address the issue of wind direction?

    -The VX175 turbine has an omnidirectional shroud, which allows it to capture energy from turbulent airflow regardless of wind direction, making it suitable for installation on the tops of buildings in urban environments.

  • What is the potential impact of the VX175 turbine on residential living?

    -The VX175 turbine has the potential to reduce noise pollution and maintenance costs due to its stationary design, which only includes moving rotor parts. It operates quietly, producing noise at about 40 decibels in 6 m/s winds.

  • What are the estimated values for annual energy production of the VX175 system?

    -The exact estimated values for annual energy production of the VX175 system are not provided in the transcript, but it is mentioned that the company's website offers these estimates. However, there isn't any publicly available performance data yet.

  • How does the VX175 turbine compare to traditional wind turbines in terms of efficiency and cost?

    -While the VX175 may not be as efficient as a large HAWT (horizontal axis wind turbine), its potential value lies in its practicality for installation and operation in more populated areas, which traditional turbines might not serve as effectively due to size and logistical constraints.

  • What are the future plans for the VX175 turbine and similar models?

    -Ventum is focusing on deploying the VX175 in commercial buildings, offices, and apartment blocks. They are also developing the VX300, a larger version of the turbine intended for industrial areas like warehouses and storage facilities.

Outlines

00:00

🌪️ Introduction to the VX175 Shrouded Wind Turbine

The video script begins with a discussion about the Aeromine rooftop wind turbine and its unique 'motionless' design. It then introduces a new turbine, the VX175, developed by Ventum Dynamics. The VX175 is notable for its shroud, a lantern-like structure that wraps around the turbine body, which is a concept that has been experimented with for decades to amplify a turbine's power output. The script also mentions a misconception about the VX175 being linked to an older concept, a Darwinian invention, which is clarified later in the script. The host, Matt Ferrell, sets the stage for a discussion on the evolution of wind turbine design and the practical considerations of size and mechanical failure.

05:02

🔍 The VX175's Connection to Erasmus Darwin's Windmill

The script delves into the supposed connection between the VX175 and an 18th-century windmill design by Erasmus Darwin, the grandfather of Charles Darwin. It is revealed that the VX175 is not a rehash of Darwin's design, but rather a modern adaptation of the IMPLUX turbine concept by engineer Varan Sureshan. The script discusses the false notion that led to the exploration of the VX175's design origins and the realization that the similarities between the two designs are coincidental rather than derived from one another. The script also highlights the innovative aspects of the VX175, such as its stationary design and the shroud's role in capturing air efficiently.

10:05

💡 The Role of Shrouded Turbines in Harnessing Wind Energy

The script explains the concept of a diffuser-augmented wind turbine (DAWT), which includes a shroud or diffuser to increase power output by concentrating wind energy and reducing tip losses. It discusses the historical interest in shrouded turbines and their potential benefits, such as increased efficiency and power output. However, it also acknowledges the economic challenges associated with shrouds, particularly when applied to traditional large-scale turbines. The script then contrasts the VX175's approach, which is designed to be economically practical for rooftop installations in urban and residential areas.

15:07

🏙️ The VX175's Urban Application and Future Prospects

The final paragraph focuses on the VX175's potential for urban environments, where it can be mounted on rooftops to capture energy from turbulent airflows. The script outlines the turbine's advantages, such as its omnidirectional shroud, low maintenance costs, and quiet operation. It also provides estimated values for annual energy production and discusses the lack of publicly available performance data. The script concludes with a note on the potential applications of the VX175 in apartment blocks and commercial buildings, as well as the upcoming release of a larger version, the VX300, for industrial areas. The host reflects on the importance of understanding the human stories behind technological developments and invites viewers to share their thoughts on the role of DAWTs in the future of wind energy.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Aeromine rooftop wind turbine

The Aeromine rooftop wind turbine is a unique design mentioned at the beginning of the video that has a 'motionless' design. It serves as a point of comparison for the new turbine introduced by Ventum Dynamics. The Aeromine's design is significant as it represents an innovative approach to harnessing wind energy in an urban setting.

💡Ventum Dynamics

Ventum Dynamics is a Norwegian company that has developed a new rooftop turbine, the VX175, which is the main focus of the video. The company is highlighted for its innovative approach to wind turbine design, specifically the use of a shroud to increase power output, which is a central theme of the video.

💡Shroud

A shroud, in the context of the video, refers to the lantern-like structure that encapsulates the rotor of the Ventum Dynamics' VX175 turbine. The shroud is designed to accelerate wind, allowing a greater volume of air to pass through the turbine, thereby increasing its power output. It is a key innovation that differentiates the VX175 from other wind turbines.

💡IMPLUX turbine

The IMPLUX turbine is an invention by engineer Varan Sureshan and is mentioned as a precursor to the VX175. It represents an earlier attempt at creating a shrouded wind turbine and is significant because it influenced the design of the VX175, despite not being directly based on Erasmus Darwin's design, as initially suspected by the video's team.

💡Erasmus Darwin

Erasmus Darwin, the grandfather of Charles Darwin, was an English physician who also invented a shrouded windmill. His invention is discussed in the video due to its visual similarity to modern shrouded turbines, although it is clarified that his design was not the basis for the VX175. His windmill is an example of an early attempt to harness wind energy more effectively.

💡Darwinian invention

The term 'Darwinian invention' in the video refers to the misconception that the Ventum Dynamics' turbine is based on an invention by Charles Darwin. It is a point of historical clarification, emphasizing that the modern turbine's design is not a continuation of Darwin's work, but rather an independent development.

💡Decentralizing power supply

Decentralizing power supply is the concept of distributing the generation of electricity away from large, centralized power stations to smaller, localized sources like rooftop turbines. The video discusses how the VX175 turbine contributes to this concept by enabling the generation of energy in urban and residential areas where large turbines may not be feasible.

💡Diffuser-augmented wind turbine (DAWT)

A DAWT, or diffuser-augmented wind turbine, is a type of wind turbine that uses a shroud, duct, or lens to increase the wind speed through the turbine, thereby increasing power output. The VX175 is an example of a DAWT, and the video explores how this design could make wind energy more viable in areas with lower wind speeds or limited space.

💡Levelized cost of energy (LCOE)

LCOE is an economic measure that compares the average cost to build and operate an electricity-generating asset over its lifetime with the total energy output of that asset. The video mentions a study where DAWTs showed a significant reduction in LCOE, indicating their potential economic viability.

💡Annual energy production (AEP)

AEP refers to the amount of energy a power generation system is expected to produce over the course of a year. The video discusses how the VX175's design could potentially increase AEP, making it a more efficient choice for urban wind energy generation.

💡Edge effect

The 'edge effect' mentioned in the video describes the phenomenon where wind hitting a building wall is redirected upwards and accelerated. Ventum Dynamics' turbine is designed to harness this effect, particularly useful in urban environments where such airflow patterns are common, to increase the turbine's power output.

Highlights

Norwegian company Ventum Dynamics has released a new rooftop wind turbine, the VX175, featuring a unique shroud design.

The VX175 is deployed along the edges of large industrial and commercial buildings, similar to the Aeromine rooftop wind turbine.

The shroud design of the VX175 is not a new concept, with researchers experimenting with covered rotors for decades to amplify power output.

The VX175 is mistakenly thought to be connected to an older concept, the Darwinian invention, by Erasmus Darwin, grandfather of Charles Darwin.

Ventum’s turbine is not based on Erasmus Darwin's design; it is a new form of the IMPLUX turbine invented by engineer Varan Sureshan.

The VX175 turbine is entirely stationary except for the rotor, aiming to promote air capture and prevent air leakage in any wind direction.

The VX175's shroud is engineered to be omnidirectional, allowing it to capture energy from turbulent airflow common in urban environments.

The turbine is designed to harness the 'edge effect' where wind is redirected upwards and accelerated by buildings.

Ventum's turbine operates quietly, producing noise at about 40 decibels in 6 m/s winds, which is considered acceptable for human health.

Annual energy production estimates for the VX175 are provided by Ventum, though no public performance data is yet available.

The VX175 is optimized for manufacturing and incorporates features from the IMPLUX turbine, with Ventum acquiring the patent for IMPLUX.

Ventum's turbine is not intended for single-family homes but is suitable for apartment blocks, commercial buildings, and offices.

A larger version of the turbine, the VX300, is being developed for industrial areas like warehouses and storage facilities.

Shrouds or diffusers in DAWTs (diffuser-augmented wind turbines) concentrate wind energy and increase power output by 2 to 5 times, as per studies.

Despite the potential increase in power, shrouds have been considered economically impractical for traditional turbines due to cost and structural integrity issues.

Ventum's approach differs from traditional turbines by utilizing the shroud on rooftop turbines, making use of low wind speeds in urban areas.

A study from the University of Tehran showed that wind lens turbines significantly reduced the levelized cost of energy and increased annual energy production.

The success of the VX175 will depend on its ability to bring turbines to more populated areas with practical installation and operational costs.